Return to Home Page

Tom Balya, Westmoreland County Commissioner: Leadership - Accountability - Results Courthouse Photo
Politics Archive
 

Keeping Us in Fear

Posted 9-7-2006

It amazes me how some Americans (though they are clearly in the minority) are still buying the Bush Administration's propaganda about the invasion of Iraq and its relationship to international terrorism. They buy the idea that somehow this conflict is of the same proportion as fighting World War II or the Cold War. Just because Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld, and their hand puppet George Bush say those things, it doesn't make it so.

The other day I received an e-mail encouraging me to wake up. Attached was a headline from 1939 when the Germans invaded Poland. I wasn't sure if the author of the e-mail was comparing terrorists to the powerful Wermacht of the Third Reich or comparing the USA to Poland. But buying these distortions from Team Cheney is absolutely foolish. There is nothing that these terrorists can do that compares to an invading army like the Wermacht. They are criminals with some weaponry at their disposal. They are fighting through random attacks against the perceived (or real) injustices inflicted upon Muslims by the West and by the governments of the Muslim world that have ties to the West.

The Nazis had the rebuilt industrial power of Europe's largest country at their disposal. Anyone that compares what Osama Bin Laden has at his disposal to what Hitler had at his either lacks judgment and understanding, or simply is buying the propaganda. Bin Laden has no consensus of support in the Muslim world or even the citizens of any particular Islamic nation on his side. Hitler had the overwhelming majority of Germans supporting him by the time he invaded Poland. He also had Germanic people in Austria and Germanic people in other sections of neighboring countries that had been taken from Germany after World War I. It is like comparing a pit bull to Tyrannosaurus Rex. They both can inflict damage but the proportionality of that damage sure is different.

Comparing international communism to the terrorists, as Bush just did in a recent speech is equally absurd. The Soviet Union, the largest country in the world, Communist China, the most populous country in the world, and all their various satellites were tremendously more capable of inflicting damage on a much larger scale than a guy hiding in the hills of Pakistan.

Calling the terrorists "fascists" is equally off base although in this instance it is almost like "the pot calling the kettle black". The term "Fascism" as coined by the Italians during the reign of Benito Mussolini was a merger of government and corporate interests into one. "Islamo fascism" is a nonsensical term. The fanatics in the Muslim world want a theocracy. They are not looking for a merging of government and business interests, but just what administration has done so since the day they took office? However, to call the Islamic fundamentalists "theocrats" would make them appear to have a similar goal to this administration's blindly loyal base; a government based on a certain group's religious beliefs.

So why is the current administration trying to use such ridiculous comparisons? It is simple; things have not gone as they had planned. The only way to control the American people, who seem to be tiring of the occupation of Iraq, is to link Iraq and terrorism and to keep the people fearful. By comparing terrorists to those historically powerful and evil enemies, that everyone has either lived through or learned about, the Cheney team can demand unquestioned obedience. And remarkably they still get it from some Americans. But the misuse of labels demeans the sacrifices made against the real "Axis of Evil". And it demeans the long geopolitical struggle that took place in the decades after World War II that saw the eventual collapse of the Soviet sphere of influence. I hope the majority of Americans have wised up to the games being played by this administration. International terrorism has been around for years and until the root causes are acknowledged and dealt with, the USA will continue down a costly, wrong path.

 

 
Top of Page
  Biography | Calendar | Campaign 2007 | E-Mail Tom | Links | Mayors' Forums | News |
Photographs | Politics | Poll Results | TribWatch | Views | Westmoreland Tomorrow | Home

Copyright © 1999-2008, Tom Balya. All rights reserved.
Paid for by the Balya for Commissioner Committee || Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania